The main causes of errors and discrepancies in the diagnosis of schizophrenia for 25 years
Abstract
Objective and subjective causes of differences and mistakes in schizophrenia diagnostics were analysed on the basis of examining of two cohorts of patients in Russia and one in Yakutia, medical documents in the period 25-30 years. The obtained results of the research demonstrate preservation of actuality of the same diagnostic problems (in hypo and hyper schizophrenia diagnosis), as 30 years ago. The assumption was made about the importance of further development of diagnostical approaches and methods.
About the Authors
S. N. Oskolkova
ГНЦ и ССП им. В.П. Сербского
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
M. V. Yakovleva
Медицинский институт СВФУ им. М.К. Аммосова
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
References
1. Agafonov S.N. Analysis of a case of misdiagnosis in patients with schizophrenia during psychiatric examination / S.N. Agafonov // Practice TEs. – 2000. – № 38. – P. 129 – 141.
2. Balashov P.P. On the mental health of men who are in intensive developed regions of Siberia / P.P. Balashov // Actual problems of psychiatry. – Tomsk, 1989. – P. 142-143.
3. Bolshakov N.B. A case of mistaken diagnosis in expert patient suffering from paranoid schizophrenia and disorders of sexual preference / N.B. Bolshakov // Practice TEs. – 2010. – № 48. – P.64-76.
4. Wasilewski V.G. A case of mistaken diagnosis of schizophrenia in the psychopathic personality / V.Wasilewski, O. Pechenkina // Ibid. – 2000 – № 38. – P.83-93.
5. Gorinov V.V. Forensic psychiatric diagnosis: the ratio of medical and psychological criteria / V. Gorinov // Proceedings of the XII Congress of Russian psychiatrists. – Moscow, 1995. – P. 460-461.
6. Dvirsky A.A. Lucid alcoholism delirium tremens brought a prognostic factor of clinical manifestations of schizophrenia / A.A. Dvirsky // Ukrainian Archives of Psychiatry. – 2002. – Volume 4, № 31. – P. 119-122.
7. Elkin S.P. The influence of exogenous factors on the recovery and for paranoid schizophrenia / S.P. Elkin // Schizophrenia and schizophrenia spectrum disorders. – M., 1999. – P. 263-265.
8. Kalinin V.V. Epileptic psychosis. Issues of phenomenology, taxonomy, pathogenesis and therapy / V. Kalinin // Psychiatry and pharmacotherapy. – 2008. – № 2. – P. 52-56.
9. Kolotilin G.F. Clinical and psychopathological pathomorphosis paranoid schizophrenia / G.F. Kolotilin, M.V. Yakovleva // Far East medical journal. – 2009. – № 3. – P.64-66.
10. Kondratiev F.V. Fate of patients with schizophrenia (clinico-social and forensic aspects) / F.V. Kondratiev. – M., 2010. – P. 401.
11. Krytskya V.P. The pathology of mental activity in schizophrenia: motivation, communication, cognition / V.P.Krytskya. – M.: Moscow State University Press, 1991. -P. 256
12. Lebedeva N.S. Outcomes of acute atypical psychoses in compulsory treatment / N. Lebedeva // Russian Journal of Psychiatry. – 2003. – № 2. – P. 24 -26.
13. Malkov K.D. Clinical – dynamic schizophrenia spectrum disorders, and combined with his alcoholism: Author. dis. ... Candidate. honey. Science / K.D.Malkov. – M., 2001. – P. 25.
14. Oskolkova S.N. Expert diagnostic errors in forensic practice / S.N. Oskolkova // Theory and organization of forensic psychiatric expertise. – Moscow, 1989. – P.67-78.
15. Oskolkova S.N. Some clinical and social aspects of the differential diagnosis of schizophrenia / S.N. Oskolkova // Journal of Neurology and Psychiatry. SS Korsakov. – 1991. – № 7. – P. 109-112.
16. Oskolkova S.N. Differential diagnosis of schizophrenia and residual-organic brain damage in atypical clinical / S.N. Oskolkova // Guidelines. – M., 1991. – P. 19.
17. Oskolkova S.N. Differential diagnosis of schizophrenia and residual-organic brain damage in psychopathic states: Author. dis. ... drs. med. science / S.N. Oskolkova. – M., 1992. – P.45.
18. Oskolkova S.N. On the differential diagnosis of schizophrenia and a personality disorder with atypical clinical picture in a serial killer / S.N. Oskolkov, T.V. Fedorova // Practice TEs. – 2000. . N38. – P. 34 – 45.
19. Shumsky N.G. Diagnostic errors in forensic psychiatry / N.G. Shumsky. – St.: Humanitarian Agency «Academic Project», 1997. – P. 390.
20. Usyukina M.V. A differential diagnosis of epileptic psychoses and endogenous / M.V. Usyukina, T.A. Shahbazi, I.M. Ushakov // Practice TEs. – 2010. – № 48. – P.14-24.
21. Yakovleva M.V. Clinical pathomorphosis schizophrenia in ethnocultural aspect: author. dis. ... candidate. med. science / M.V. Yakovleva. – M., 2011. – P. 26.
22. Kanemoto K. Review of neuropsychiatry epilepsy / K. Kanemoto. – Cambridge, 2002. – P.160.
23. Skondlar B. Psychopathology of schizophrenia in Slovenia from 1881 to 2000.: Changes in key symptoms of schizophrenia / B. Skondlar, M. Dernovsek, M. Kosmar // International Journal of Social Psychiatry. – 2008. – № 2. – P. 101 – 111.
24. Selton J. Risk of schizophrenia among the patients of Moroccan origin in Denmark / J. Selton, J. Blom, Dirk // Review of schizophrenia. – 2008. – № 104 – P. 274 – 278.
25. Weisman A. Comparative analysis of the clinical symptoms of schizophrenia in patients of Mexican and English descent in America / A.Weisman, S.Laura // Bulletin of schizophrenia. – 2000. – № 26. – P. 107 – 118.
Review
For citations:
Oskolkova S.N., Yakovleva M.V. The main causes of errors and discrepancies in the diagnosis of schizophrenia for 25 years. Yakut Medical Journal. 2012;(4):72-76. (In Russ.)
Views:
1
Email this article 